Before you hire, these questions to ask an SEO agency reveal who will do real work and who will sell you vague promises. Use them in your next call.

About strategy

1. What would you do in the first 90 days? 2. How do you choose which keywords and pages matter? 3. How do you handle local SEO and Google Business Profile? 4. What is your approach to AI search and answer engines? A good agency answers with a process tailored to your business.

About work and links

5. Who writes and approves content? 6. How do you build links and mentions, and will you show me examples? 7. Do you ever use paid or automated links? 8. How do you fix technical issues, and who implements them? Be wary of secret tactics.

Key takeaways

  • Ask about process, not promises.
  • Demand transparent reporting and tie it to leads.
  • Clarify link building and content practices.
  • Ask how they approach AI search (AEO).

About measurement

9. What will you report each month? 10. Will I have access to Search Console and analytics? 11. How do you tie SEO to leads and revenue? 12. What are realistic milestones in months three, six and twelve?

About the relationship

13. Who will I talk to day to day? 14. How do you handle changes in Google’s algorithm? 15. What do you need from me? 16. What is the notice period? 17. What happens to my site and data if we part ways?

How to use the answers

Look for plain language, specifics and willingness to say ‘it depends.’ Ask for a sample report. For pricing context, read our guide to SEO costs in NYC.

Listen for specifics

Strong answers mention your market, your competitors and concrete first steps. Weak answers repeat buzzwords or promise results. If an answer sounds like it could apply to any business, ask for an example.

Ask to see work

Request a sample audit, a sample report and examples of pages they have optimized. Ask what the client’s results were and what the agency did to cause them.

Think about AI search too

More discovery now happens inside AI assistants. Ask how the agency structures content so assistants can understand and cite your business, and how they track visibility across both search and AI tools.

What a strong answer sounds like

Asked how they would approach your site, a strong agency might say: ‘We would start with an audit, look at your top revenue pages, fix technical issues, improve titles and content, build out service and location pages, and set up tracking so we can show leads.’ A weak answer promises a number-one ranking by a date.

Red flags in the answers

Refusal to share examples, vague descriptions of link building, promises of instant results, no mention of your business goals and no access to reports. Any of these deserves a follow-up question.

Follow up with a pilot

If you like an agency but want to reduce risk, begin with a paid audit or a short pilot focused on a few pages. You will learn how they work before committing further.

Frequently asked questions

Should I ask for guaranteed rankings?

Treat guarantees as a red flag. Search engines control rankings.

How many references should I request?

Two or three clients with similar goals.

What if they will not share reports?

That is a reason to look elsewhere.

Do I need to understand SEO?

No, but ask them to explain it simply.

Related reading

Want to see how we answer these? Let’s talk ⟶

Work with Sitting Pretty Creative

Want this done for you?

We are a growth marketing and AI agency in New York City and San Diego. Tell us where your business is today and we will come back with a plan and a budget that makes sense.

Let’s make something happen ⟶Explore SEO & AEO ⟶