Spotting red flags when hiring a marketing agency can save months and money. Here are twelve warning signs and what healthier agencies do instead.
Promises that sound too good
Guaranteed rankings, guaranteed sales or ‘secret’ techniques are warning signs. Real marketing involves testing and uncertainty, and honest agencies explain it.
Lack of transparency
No access to ad accounts, analytics or reports, or accounts opened in the agency’s name, leave you stuck if you leave. You should own your data and accounts.
Key takeaways
- Beware guaranteed results and secret methods.
- You should own your ad accounts, data and creative.
- Insist on clear scope and reporting.
- Healthy agencies ask questions and explain tradeoffs.
Vague scope
If you cannot say what you will get each month, you cannot judge value. Look for specific deliverables and timelines.
One-size-fits-all plans
An agency that pitches the same package to everyone has not learned your business. Good proposals reference your goals and market.
Pressure and long lock-ins
High-pressure sales and long contracts with no exit are risky. Healthy agencies are comfortable with reasonable terms.
No one to talk to
Slow replies, constant account manager turnover and no access to senior people predict problems. Ask about communication before you sign.
What to look for instead
Clarity, plain language, relevant case studies, honest forecasts and an eagerness to measure. Our guide on choosing an agency gives a full checklist.
Green flags to look for
A candid discussion of risks, a plan with milestones, welcoming questions about pricing and contracts, examples that match your industry, a named team and an eagerness to give you access to your own data.
How to protect yourself
Put ownership of ad accounts, analytics and creative in writing. Pay platforms directly. Ask for a clear scope and reporting schedule. Keep notice periods reasonable.
If you already see warning signs
Raise them directly and ask for a written plan to address them. If there is no improvement, request your accounts and data and begin planning a transition.
A pre-signing checklist
- Do I own all ad accounts, analytics and creative?
- Is the scope written down with monthly deliverables?
- Is the reporting schedule defined?
- Do I know who will work on my account?
- Is the notice period reasonable?
- Have I spoken to at least two references?
What to do if you feel pressured
Pause. A good agency will give you time to review a proposal. If you are told the price disappears tomorrow, treat it as a warning.
Trust but verify
Ask for access to dashboards, spot-check reports against your own sales and keep your own records. Healthy relationships can withstand verification.
Frequently asked questions
Is a red flag always a dealbreaker?
Not always, but ask about it directly and judge the answer.
How do I check an agency’s reputation?
Talk to references and read independent reviews.
What if I already signed?
Review the contract, request access to your accounts and set clear milestones.
Do big agencies avoid these problems?
Not necessarily. Size does not guarantee quality.
Related reading
- Consulting — our service page
- Growth Marketing — our service page
- Marketing Analytics — our service page
- Browse client case studies
- Every marketing service we offer, explained
Want a transparent partner? Let’s talk ⟶
Work with Sitting Pretty Creative
Want this done for you?
We are a growth marketing and AI agency in New York City and San Diego. Tell us where your business is today and we will come back with a plan and a budget that makes sense.