CAFE BY THE GIRLS: CAFE WEBSITE DESIGN FOR TWO LOCATIONS AND ONE VOICE

A custom site for a Colombian coffee shop in Chelsea and Park Slope, with Square ordering built in and copy that took as long as the code.

  • ClientCafe by the Girls
  • IndustryColombian coffee and food
  • LocationChelsea and Park Slope, NY
  • What we didWebsite design and development, Square integration
The brief, in our words

Two cafes, one website. The cafe website design had to let customers order ahead and pay through Square without leaving the site, and the whole thing had to sound like Cafe by the Girls, not like a coffee shop template.

Our summary of the brief
The cafe

From the coffee fields to 23rd Street

  • Chelsea original on W 23rd St, since 2021
  • Park Slope cafe on 7th Ave, 2025
  • Single-origin Colombian coffee from women farmers
  • Pandequeso, empanadas, ceremonial matcha

Cafe by the Girls serves single-origin Colombian coffee alongside the food that keeps a neighborhood coming back: pandequeso, empanadas, an all-day breakfast, ceremonial matcha for the afternoon crowd. The original opened in Chelsea in 2021. Four years later a second cafe opened in Park Slope, and the question of a website stopped being optional.

Two addresses is where most small-business sites quietly break. One phone number, one set of hours, a menu that may or may not apply to the place you are standing in front of. We were asked for a site that treated both cafes as equals and still read as one brand.

What was built

Four decisions that shaped the site

  • Ordering inside the site

    Online orders run through Square and the checkout lives on the website itself, so a customer never bounces to a third-party page and the cafe keeps a single system for the counter and the web.

  • Location pages that do real work

    Each cafe has its own hours, address, directions and menu, reachable in one tap from anywhere on the site. The homepage introduces the brand; the location pages close the sale.

  • The story up front

    The site leads with the cafe's own line, From the Colombian coffee fields to the streets of New York, so the first thing a visitor learns is why this cafe exists, not just what it sells.

  • Copy as a design element

    Headlines, menu descriptions and the story page were drafted, read aloud and redrafted until they sounded like the cafe. More rounds than a normal build. The right number for this one.

A website that sounds like someone else is not finished, no matter how well it works.

The functional build was done well before the copy was. We kept going because a cafe built on Colombian identity cannot launch with generic coffee-shop language, and the client could hear the difference between close and right.
How we can help

Your cafe deserves a site that sounds like you

Sitting Pretty Creative builds websites for New York cafes and restaurants that take orders, serve every location and read like the business wrote them. If your site feels like a template, that is fixable.

Talk to us about your website ⟶
For anyone opening a second location

Fix the website before the second awning goes up. The moment you have two addresses, every page that assumes one becomes a small daily annoyance for customers: wrong hours, wrong menu, a map pin on the other side of the river.

Build the site so each location can stand alone, keep ordering on your own domain, and budget time for the words. The design can be approved in a meeting. The voice has to be earned over a few drafts, and it is the part people remember.

— Sitting Pretty Creative

Two locations and one tired website?

Tell us about both. We will build one site that serves them properly.

Book a consultation ⟶