Before you spend another dollar, run a local business marketing audit. These 12 questions cover the places growth usually leaks: listings, reviews, website, tracking, ads, email and follow-up. Answer them honestly and you have a priority list.

Listings and local search

1. Is your Google Business Profile claimed, complete and accurate? Hours, categories, services, photos and a working website link. 2. Are Apple Business Connect, Yelp and Bing consistent? Duplicate or wrong listings confuse customers and search engines. 3. Do you appear when someone searches for your service plus your neighborhood? Search it on your phone and see. Our listings checklist covers the details.

Reviews and reputation

4. Do you have a steady flow of recent reviews? One burst from two years ago does not help. 5. Do you reply to reviews, good and bad? Replies show prospects how you treat people.

Website and conversion

6. Does the site load quickly on mobile and make the next step obvious? A visible phone number, booking link or order button matters more than a clever design. 7. Does each service or location have its own useful page? That is how you capture specific searches.

Tracking and ads

8. Can you tell where leads come from? GA4, call tracking, form tracking and a simple “how did you hear about us” question. 9. If you run ads, are they tied to real customers? Measure cost per booking or lead, not clicks.

Retention and follow-up

10. Do you capture emails or phone numbers with permission? 11. Do customers hear from you after the first visit? A welcome note or reminder is often enough. 12. Does someone respond to enquiries within the hour? Speed to reply wins jobs and tables.

Score yourself

Mark each answer red, yellow or green. Reds become the first month of work. Yellows are month two. Greens are your strengths and show where to spend ad money confidently. If you want a second pair of eyes, that is what a growth marketing audit is for.

A four-week action plan

  • Day 1: Answer questions one to six and mark each red, yellow or green.
  • Day 2: Answer questions seven to twelve.
  • Day 3: Rank the reds by impact and cost to fix.
  • Day 4 onward: Fix one red per week and re-score monthly.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Answering optimistically.
  • Fixing greens first because they are fun.
  • Skipping the phone test.
  • No owner for follow-through.

What to measure

  • Number of reds.
  • Time to reply to inquiries.
  • Review volume.

How we would approach it

Our approach is to measure first, fix the obvious leaks and then test a small number of channels against your real numbers. From there we run small experiments, report what each new customer costs and scale what works, using our Growth Marketing and Local Listings Management work as the backbone. If you would like a second set of eyes on your own situation, tell us about your business.

Key takeaways

  • Most local marketing problems are basics left undone, not missing tactics.
  • Check listings, reviews, website and tracking before buying ads.
  • Score each answer red, yellow or green to build a priority list.
  • Fix reds first; they are usually the cheapest wins.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an audit take?

A first pass with these questions takes an hour or two. A deeper audit with tracking and competitor review takes longer.

Should I audit before hiring an agency?

It helps. Knowing your starting point makes any engagement more focused and easier to measure.

What do I do with a lot of reds?

Do not panic. Fix the cheapest and most visible ones first, such as listings, reviews and your main call to action.

Related reading

Want us to run the audit with you? Get in touch ⟶

Work with Sitting Pretty Creative

Want this done for you?

We are a growth marketing and AI agency in New York City and San Diego. Tell us where your business is today and we will come back with a plan and a budget that makes sense.

Let’s make something happen ⟶Explore Growth Marketing ⟶