- ClientUnregular Pizza
- IndustryPizzeria
- LocationUnion Square, NY
- What we didOrganic social media, brand collaborations, influencer management
It started with a trade
- 135 4th Ave
- Roman square slices, 72-hour dough
- Began as a pizza barter during the 2020 lockdown
- Known for stunts like a burrata pizza wrapped in 24-karat gold
Unregular Pizza started as a lockdown barter in 2020, Roman-style pizza traded for other people's food, and grew into a shop on 4th Avenue with a square slice, a 72-hour dough and a taste for the theatrical. A business with a story like that has one marketing obligation: keep the story moving, and brand collaborations turned out to be the engine.
Not an occasional partnership, but a weekly habit that put a new audience in front of the pizzeria every seven days.
How each one worked
- ChooseFind a partner that fits
Coffee shops, breweries, authors, musicians, local New York brands and a studio like Warner Bros. Big names bring reach; local names bring credibility.
- MakeFilm it together
Content filmed with the partner each week, built around something the two brands share. That is what makes it worth posting about on both sides.
- PublishPost to both audiences
Each collaboration combined their audience with ours, so Unregular reached people who had never heard of a square slice and the partner reached pizza people. Audience arithmetic, repeated weekly.
- SustainKeep the story underneath
Alongside the collaborations, the regular social program on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok carried the product, the behind-the-scenes and the barter origin, so new followers understood why the place exists.
Collaborations borrow someone else's reach
A restaurant's organic reach is capped by its own followers and by what the platforms choose to show them. Every collaboration lends it another audience, one that arrives with a built-in endorsement from a brand they already follow.
Done once, that is a nice bump. Done weekly with partners who fit, it compounds, and the account grows through introductions rather than through ad spend. The barter that started the business is, in a sense, still how it markets itself.
Asked often
How do you get big brands to collaborate with a small restaurant?
A distinctive product, a story worth attaching to and a track record of collaborations done well. Brands look for partners who will make them look good, and a visible history of successful local collabs is the best pitch.
Are weekly collaborations sustainable?
With a system, yes. A running list of prospects, a simple format for what each collaboration produces, and content captured in one session per week. Without a system, it becomes exhausting within a month.
What makes a collaboration fail?
No real output and no shared audience. If the only artifact is a cross-post, neither audience has a reason to care.
We run collaborations every week
Sitting Pretty Creative finds, films and manages brand and creator collaborations for New York food businesses, from neighborhood shops to national names.
Plan your collaborations ⟶Collaboration checklist
- List businesses whose customers should be yours and whose customers would be glad to meet you.
- Insist that each collaboration produce something: a product, an event, a story. A tagged photo is not a collaboration.
- Alternate reach partners with credibility partners so the feed never tips into pure stunt or pure neighborhood.
- Agree that both sides post, and when.
- Keep a steady base of your own content so new arrivals find a story, not just a string of partnerships.
More case studies
Who should you be collaborating with?
Tell us about your customers. We will find the partners and run the calendar.